Entertainment

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

Jedward should follow Susan Boyle's example of not winning

The Write Factor: The Jedward phenomenon should not be downcast about losing out. Susan Boyle didn't win either and look what's happened to her, says David Coyle

David Coyle

By David Coyle

23 November 2009 10:48 GMT

139278
Jedward should follow Susan Boyle's example of not winning

I’m still gutted. OK, so there was an obvious gulf in quality between the two of them and I’ll grudgingly admit the result was the right one...no, I’m not talking about Celtic. Jedward getting the boot from The X-Factor is what’s on my mind.

Like it said in the 80s Kit-Kat ad, Jedward can’t sing, they can’t dance and they look awful. But they’re fun and they shouldn’t be too downhearted about losing. Just ask Susan Boyle. Six months ago, most of the country, and the world, was stunned when the wee wummin from Blackburn went on stage and let it rip. And last night she was on the same bill as diva Mariah Carey. I wonder who had the bigger entourage? Can’t imagine Mariah getting the bus to go and buy a dress for the show.

But SuBo didn’t actually win the talent contest she was in. She came second to..who was it now..dancing is ringing a bell..they must have been good though – never mind. It hasn’t mattered to Susan. She has had her life turned upside down – for good and bad – since she made her bid to be a professional singer and now she has her debut album coming out.

Now let’s not get carried away. Susan can obviously sing, while John and Edward..well, let’s say they are at least enthusiastic about performing, and that’s being very kind. But my 10-year-old son and his pals aren’t jumping around the school playground doing Subo impersonations – they want to be Jedward. But 10-year-olds obviously can’t afford the texts to vote for the brothers Grimes, and so some bland Robbie Williams wannabe made it through to the next round. That for me is the real shame.

I’ve got a feeling that we haven’t seen the last of John and Edward. Louis Walsh knows how to make money in show business, and if he has any sense, he’ll get them into kids TV presenting. And if Louis is reading this, he can contact me for my cut for that brilliant idea.

Maybe I’m in a minority, as it seems the public grew tired of Jedward. But they didn’t last as long as they did because of their singing ability – it was entertainment and a degree of "Let’s watch car crash TV" that kept them in the competition.
The public can be cruel. Just ask Katie Price. She also came second in her first visit to The I’m A Celebrity jungle – to Kerry Katona, that ideal role model – but gathered a whole army of new fans who saw Katie Price, not the busty businesswoman Jordan.

But second time round, it hasn’t worked out quite so well. The break-up of her jungle-born marriage to Peter Andre, which we all watched, seems to have made her the pantomime villain again, and she has quit the camp after daily trials and an exotic diet of bugs forced on her by the public.

To be fair though, Katie didn’t really need the £100,000 she’s reportedly getting paid for her time in the jungle. Maybe the public thought she was fair game. Come to think of it, pay me that kind of money and I’ll eat all the kangaroo testicles I can stomach. But I think Jedward will get the call before me.


David Coyle is a finalist in stv.tv's The Write Factor competition. The views expressed are not necessarily those of STV plc. If you would like to read more from this writer, use our comment system below.

Ads by Google

Share

There are 8 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Default avatar

    1. 23 Nov 2009 15:17Butchthejag said

    car crash tv indeed so far away from all of us and yet close enough for us to all be part of!

    Report as unsuitable

  2. Default avatar

    2. 23 Nov 2009 15:25Paul67 said

    Could not stand the lads but can't argue with your point that "some bland Robbie Williams wannabe made it through to the next round".

    The Kit Kat analogy is true, wish I'd thought of it.

    Report as unsuitable

  3. Default avatar

    3. 23 Nov 2009 16:42Gordon_J said

    Don't watch any of these programmes! Can't help but hear the names though as it's about all people talk about unfortunately.

    Report as unsuitable

  4. Default avatar

    4. 23 Nov 2009 16:59twists n turns said

    The very medium which we are using to communicate our thoughts on Subo is the real catalyst in elevating her to worldwide stardom. Had her appearance on "Britains got talent" not been captured on you tube, her runner up spot would have seen her in the limelight for a very short period.

    However, due to the worldwide exposure afforded to her by the internet, she managed to achieve something overnight that it took true greats such as "the Beatles" considerably longer to achieve.

    The world is truly at our fingertips!

    Report as unsuitable

  5. Default avatar

    5. 23 Nov 2009 18:45stephen67 said

    don't usually watch the show as I manage to stay out long enough o miss it on a Saturday evening,

    watched it last night with daughter of 9, she is sad that they have gone, must have been entertaining then.I am sure they will get a few pounds out of it just like Susan Boyle

    Report as unsuitable

  6. Default avatar

    6. 23 Nov 2009 22:14SFTB said

    I don't watch X Factor.

    It is truly unimportant and produces no lasting talent in its winners. Leona Lewis may be an exception.

    They just want the girls to fit a pre-existing model such as Beyonce or Mariah and the boys are not allowed to stray too far from Boyzone territory.

    Pop has eaten itself. Bring back Opportunity Knocks. At least the winners were allowed to profit from their own "talent" not having to sell their soul to Simplistic Simon.

    And, David, I would eat those kangaroo testicles if they promised not to make any more of those shows.

    Well, apart from Strictly, that is.

    Report as unsuitable

  7. Avatar for firesniffer

    7. 25 Nov 2009 11:27firesniffer said

    Well your wish has come true :)

    They are returning home tomorrow to do the late late christmas toy show on RTE 1 Ireland's primary tv channel. I can just imagine them, they will be worst than the kids they have on it.

    They have been offered 100.000 to take the place of katie on I am a celeb get me out of here, does anyone know if they took up the offer, they had to have a reply in by 17.00hrs yesterday.

    They have an offer on the table also of 250,000 euro for an auto-biography that also has to be decided. But Mammy now has stepped in and she wants her bouys to return to a normal life, if that's possible ..

    what do you think will a normal life be possible after the hype they have just endured ..

    Report as unsuitable

  8. Avatar for firesniffer

    8. 25 Nov 2009 11:30firesniffer said

    Well your wish has come true :)

    They are returning home tomorrow to do the late late christmas toy show on RTE 1 Ireland's primary tv channel. I can just imagine them, they will be worst than the kids they have on it.

    They have been offered 100.000 to take the place of katie on I am a celeb get me out of here, does anyone know if they took up the offer, they had to have a reply in by 17.00hrs yesterday.

    They have an offer on the table also of 250,000 euro for an auto-biography that also has to be decided. But Mammy now has stepped in and she wants her bouys to return to a normal life, if that's possible ..

    what do you think will a normal life be possible after the hype they have just endured ..

    Report as unsuitable

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

STV heats up this winter

 

Watch now

Video