Entertainment

You're not signed in
Sign in
Sign up

Has Simon Cowell Ruined The X-Factor?

You're all still talking about it, aren't you? that's because Simon Scowl is way ahead of you, argues Sara Firth.

By Sara Firth

13 November 2009 11:56 GMT

137014
Has Simon Cowell Ruined The X-Factor?

It’s been a week of berating, griping, anger and venting, with Facebook, Twitter, newspapers and TV bursting at the seams with complaints about a certain Mr Cowell’s behaviour on The  X Factor last week. Since deciding to take the final two down to the public vote (which just happened to be lovely Welsh songbird Lucie and his arch nemeses Jedward), all hell has broken loose.

So he must be quaking in his high heeled boots ahead of this weeks show right? Wrong!

Simon Scowl, my friends, has played another blinder and we all fell for it hook, line and Jedward.

You could see him, week on week, getting more and more irate as the twins continued to elude his control and grow in popularity despite his scathing put downs.  So what does he do? That’s right; out he comes and throws the twins a lifeline!

The scoundrel! The absolute hypocrite!

Or, people… or….   He’s the owner of an overhyped yet super addictive show that thrives on controversy and press coverage.  If no-one’s talking about the show, well exactly, no one would be talking about the show. And that just wouldn’t do.

But Simon had to go one better. Not only did he put himself firmly in the burning spotlight this week by appearing to back the twins, he’s also effectively swiped away their upper hand.

Cute as they are, most of us were only voting to annoy him, weren’t we?  Now he seems to like them all, we’re left with is some slightly over-enthusiastic, rosy-cheeked boys who can’t sing or dance!

You have to hand it to him, it’s all pretty smart.

But…. playing this game with the public is all well and good, and for the most part let’s face it he gets away with the whole, "my word is gospel" straight-talking nonsense. Still as much as you have to admire his way with words there’s something a little off.

No it’s not the dodgy haircut, it’s the way he sits there week after week, looking bored, forgetting the name’s of the acts, stifling yawns and ITS HIS SHOW!

He created the X Factor beast, thrust it upon us all and now he has the cheek to act like it’s barely worth his time.  It’s like being disappointed at your own turd.

So here’s what I propose…as a lesson to Mr Cowell I think we need to systematically start voting his acts out.  Doesn’t matter who wins (preferably Jedward) as long as it’s not one of his acts.

Because as much as he is a force to be reckoned with and admired, it’s time to remind the little guy that this show is X Factor and not a game of Simon Says.

Sara Firth is a finalist in stv.tv's Write Factor competition. The views expressed are not necessarily those of STV plc. If you would like to read more from this writer, use our comment system below.

Ads by Google

Share

There are 6 comments

You need to be logged in to comment.

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

  1. Avatar for firesniffer

    1. 13 Nov 2009 14:32firesniffer said

    Sara, what a classic piece of er .. I forgot I cant swear ah well.

    But Sara where have you been all week, it's not as if every person who watches xfactor and has a brain can not see what simon is playing at is it.

    I made a comment to this effect on Monday as I recall, but not I did not go as far as being petty and telling the public to vote out perfectly good singers, now Sara that is wreckless. That is worst than Danni threatening to leave xfactor if the twins won, in order to get the public not to vote for the twins.

    Surely Sara, you don't believe for one second the twins will win do you, they don't need to win they are already winners.

    And the sooner people realise that and credit them for that the sooner a little bit of sanity will creep back into the show and we will get on with what it's really about singing.

    Now I am going to say this one more time, the twins are winners they have multi million euro contracts awaiting, and guess what simon gets the biggest slice of the jackpot yet again as they are under his contract until 2010.

    So please please please don't take Sara's advice keep on voting for olly and stacy Joe and Danyl, and give the crown of the xfactor to someone who can sing. This week will see Lloyd and the twins in the bottom two, and one thing is for sure the judges will make sure the twins go home as I doubt very much the deadlock card will be played again, for this season anyway ..

    Report as unsuitable

  2. Default avatar

    2. 14 Nov 2009 09:43MissX said

    Olly can't sing.... Jamie Archer to win!!!

    Report as unsuitable

  3. Default avatar

    3. 14 Nov 2009 15:35Spart said

    The only real winner in this is SyCo, aka simon Cowell's company and its not a singing contest at all, its a talent show for entertainment purposes. Vote for whoever you want for any reason you want, as long as you enjoy the taking part. The British music industry is not going to fall apart if the twins Win it...

    Report as unsuitable

  4. Default avatar

    4. 15 Nov 2009 23:13rachel1987 said

    Well Firesniffer (great name by the way, did you steal that off a twelve year old boy) i think after the recent results you have been firmly put in your place. The public love Jedward! and do u know why we love them, because this year we don't have any superstars. lets face it we're not going to get the next leona out of this one, so just have fun with the show. In reference to the patronizing tone you take Firesniffer, you seem to be really offended by the situation. Why not give yourself a break and watch Strictly Come Dancing instead. Perhaps you can focus your outrage on Aleshas poor judging skills. In the meantime crack on Jedward, I'd love to shake the hand of your choreographer.

    Report as unsuitable

  5. Default avatar

    5. 15 Nov 2009 23:20rachel1987 said

    Well Firesniffer (great name by the way, did you steal that off a twelve year old boy) i think after the recent results you have been firmly put in your place. The public love Jedward! and do u know why we love them, because this year we don't have any superstars. lets face it we're not going to get the next leona out of this one, so just have fun with the show. In reference to the patronizing tone you take Firesniffer, you seem to be really offended by the situation. Why not give yourself a break and watch Strictly Come Dancing instead. Perhaps you can focus your outrage on Aleshas poor judging skills. In the meantime crack on Jedward, I'd love to shake the hand of your choreographer.

    Report as unsuitable

  6. Default avatar

    6. 16 Nov 2009 15:00KellsBells said

    I absolutely love Jedward! They are so much fun, they're the only reason why I watch the X Factor. The whole point of the show is for the public to vote to keep the acts in that they want to see and the public wants to see Jedward, me included. If it was a pure contest of talent and singing abilities then there would be talented judges/vocal coaches making the decision.

    Report as unsuitable

You need to be logged in to comment.

sign in

Don't have a mySTV account? Create one now it's easy

Posts are not actively monitored by STV. The views expressed are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of STV.

Weatherwatch with Sean Batty on STV

 

Watch now

Video